Why Does Once Upon a Time Have a Problem With Consent?

Long running ABC show Once Upon a Time has questions to answer regarding one of its latest storylines


Spoilers Below. Trigger Warning for non-consensual sex.

Controversy hit Reddit and Tumblr on Saturday as fairy tale drama Once Upon A Time, created yet another storyline with dubious consent at its heart.

UK fans however, had to wait until Tuesday to judge for themselves, when the episode premiered on Netflix. So judgement made? It’s pretty obvious – the storyline in question features rape by deception. Magical deception, no less.

It’s not even the first time the writers have used this storyline – and both times, this magical deception has resulted in a child.

However, in almost every instance, the victims of sexual assault have been men.

The most recent in question features Captain Hook (an anti-hero in this story) climbing a tower, where he finds a woman he assumes is Rapunzel, being held prisoner from the witch he is hoping to avoid. After he brings the necessary ingredients to free her from the tower, Rapunzel thanks him with a night between the sheets – but next morning? It turns out that the prisoner was in fact Mother Gothel all along – and she used Hook in order to create a baby to take her place in the tower.

If that situation had been reversed, the outcry would have been everywhere. As it is, the showrunners have repeatedly used similar storylines as mentioned above.

In Season Four, Robin Hood resumed his relationship with a woman he thought was his wife Maid Marian – only to discover she’d been dead the entire time, and the woman he’d been sleeping with was Zelena, the Wicked Witch of the West. This again results in pregnancy, much to the horror of everyone bar Zelena – she is determined to keep her baby.

Zelena is actually a multiple offender – she also holds Rumplestiltskin prisoner and repeatedly violates his personal space, relishing in his discomfort. While Rumple changes his moral alignment as often as his socks, and his own relationships are just as messed up, he’s also married and at this point severely mentally unstable.

But OUAT’s consent problem goes right back to the first season, when Big Bad ‘Evil Queen’ Regina uses the Huntsman as a sex slave for the best part of 28 years. He has no idea that this is going on, due to her control being magic based, but by his last episode, he is beginning to break out of Regina’s control. So what does she do? Literally crushes his heart and he dies in hero Emma’s arms.

This is barely addressed by the show, and Regina has now ended up as one of the good guys. (Permanently this time).

And it’s not as if the problem has not been called out by numerous publications, both now and in the past. The Mary Sue, and io9 have both called out the show, and many fans are disgusted.

Yet according to show runner Adam Horwitz, Graham (the Huntsman) had free will, and he’s remained suspiciously silent on this weekend’s storyline. Not only that, but in the commentary for A Land without Magic (the season one finale) show runner Edward Kitsis said: “I love how [the Queen] just abuses [the huntsman], that he’s basically just a trapped sex slave”.

adam horowitz

Sexual assault is a huge issue right now, what with the numerous Hollywood allegations that have come to light. Sexual assault is an awful thing to experience regardless of gender, and frankly, Rape as a Plot device is lazy and hackneyed. The fact that OUAT uses it to show the nobility of its male victims is even more troublesome.

Given that the show repeatedly praises itself for being feminist, it almost seems as if OUAT thinks that its take on sexual assault and rape is in and of itself feminist. If this is the case (which, please, let it not be), then no, just no. Sexual assault is not a plot device, and the treatment of the characters involved is gross, not progress. Please stop it.

3 thoughts on “Why Does Once Upon a Time Have a Problem With Consent?

  1. Its not a new phenomena with these show runner and it becoming concerned for people running a family show its their third rape by deceive and second rape baby without any discussed in the show on how troubling this events can be for anyone! And, the explain that them or their cast is poor at best and dangerous in a era marking with a adware toward those issues. Cause, it goes to denying what they are portraying is rape by deceive to encourage myth as such that a rape victims cannot feels any pleasure! At, this point Dysney shpuld be aware that what their media send as messages! So, I salut you to spoke about it!

    Like

  2. Going into season 7, i was not particular happy about it, seeing as their were too many changes, and characters leaving esp one of my favourites and who was the protagonist of the show.
    I knew at some point the writers will either taint the characters or prop up something in the story.
    Having lost Emma Swan, and the love story i have loved for seasons with Hook. We also lost Real version Hook. As the show brought in Wish version Hook (which that wish arc never really made any sense in season 6). I am disappointed to see that after losing them for like four or five episodes, the writers thought it was ok to see any version of Hook kissing someone (not something i wanted to see) and then later on reveal what really happened…. it was Rape by Deception. I am disgusted as fan, as person, and as long time viewer who could remember this show fondly but in season 7 as a whole, its just going downhill. Plot points dont make anymore such more then before, and the wacky timelines that i believe even the writers dont know anymore.
    What the writers have done to their own show is just so disappointing…

    Like

  3. ***please remember this is Wish Hook, another entity on its own not the real original Hook. (i just dont want viewers reading getting confused here) make the distinction!

    The real version Hook is back in Storybrooke with his wife Emma Swan and unborn child.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s